Snehashish roy
Actor Alia Bhatt has found herself at the centre of an online debate after a clip from her hosting stint at the Screen Awards 2026 went viral, prompting discussions about whether live hosting requires a specialised skill set distinct from acting.
The conversation began when a content creator shared a video of Bhatt hosting the awards ceremony alongside comedian Zakir Khan. The clip quickly gained traction on social media, with several users pointing out what they perceived as awkward pauses and lack of spontaneity during the segment.
The viral post argued that hosting is a distinct craft that demands improvisation, timing and audience engagement, suggesting that not all actors may be suited for live stage anchoring. The critique resonated with a section of viewers, leading to a wider discussion about how hosting roles are often assigned in the entertainment industry.
Amid the debate, television host Mini Mathur weighed in, agreeing with the broader sentiment that hosting requires specialised skills. Mathur, who has extensive experience as a presenter across television shows and live events, stated that anchoring is not the same as acting and involves a different set of abilities, particularly the capacity to think on one’s feet.
She emphasised that live hosting demands spontaneity and real-time audience connection, which can only be developed through experience. Her remarks highlighted the distinction between scripted performances and unscripted stage presence, reinforcing the idea that hosting is a profession in its own right.
The discussion also brought attention to a broader trend in the industry, where established film actors are often chosen to host award functions due to their popularity and star appeal. Critics of this practice argued that while star power may draw viewership, it does not necessarily translate into effective hosting.
At the same time, some users defended Bhatt, noting that the Screen Awards marked one of her early attempts at live hosting. They pointed out that hosting is a skill that improves over time and that even seasoned performers can face challenges in unscripted formats.
Bhatt, one of the leading actors in Hindi cinema, made her hosting debut at the 2026 Screen Awards, an appearance that has since drawn mixed reactions online. While some praised her effort to step outside her comfort zone, others felt that the performance highlighted the differences between acting for the screen and engaging a live audience.
The debate has also extended to industry practices, with discussions around whether professional hosts should be prioritised for such events. Mathur’s comments, given her background as a long-time television presenter, added weight to this perspective, underlining the technical and performative demands of the role.
The episode reflects how moments from high-profile events can quickly become focal points for larger conversations about skill, professionalism and industry norms. It also highlights the scrutiny faced by celebrities when they venture into roles beyond their primary domain.